On , 2012, the Council for Endangered Species Act Reliability (CESAR) filed an appeal of a federal district court decision which held that challenges to EPA pesticide registrations for failing to consult on endangered species impacts must be brought under FIFRA, not under the Endangered Species Act .  The district court therefore concluded that FIFRA requires CESAR’s challenge to be brought in a federal court of appeals, and not in the district court as the ESA requires. CESAR’s appeal is filed in the United State Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit.

● The notice of appeal is attached below.